Discussion
Yorio
The implication behind each factor in the list was that each factor was necessary to describe the L2 learning process, and in 1976 Yorio had the wisdom not to claim that together the factors were sufficient to map the terrain.
필요는 한 요소들이지만, 충분하지는 않다.
Lightbown
Long (2007) suggested that SLA theories (let’s call them tapestries) must conform to traditional logic by fulfilling two conditions: (1) necessity—a condition that must be satisfied, and (2) sufficiency—the condition is enough to prove a point and we are therefore assured of the truth of a statement. You could make the case that each of Yono’s statements was necessary for your tapestry, and even that a claim for their interdependence is necessary. But certainly that also implies that (a) no single factor is sufficient alone, and more importantly, that (b) all of the factors together may not be sufficient to explain all of SLA.
필요는 한 요소들이지만, 충분하지는 않다.
Did you notice how Ellis’s ten observations are much more full of hedges than the previous claims? Only observation 1 is unequivocal in claiming the condition of necessity (observation *4 offers a hedge in the word “often”). The rest offer considerable wiggle room, but still lay claim to certain domains as important factors in a theory of SLA. This may be the effect of a field that is more willing to identify areas of inquiry, but less willing to make strong claims on their predictability or directionality, and perhaps for good reason as the complexity of SLA is unveiled.
1번 제외하고는 꼭 필요한 것은 아니다.
Brown :??
SLA 언어, 학습자, 학습의 환경
① controlled vs automatic
controlled: learning new skill, beginner
automatic: accomplished skill, advanced
② peripheral 지엽적인 vs focal
peripheral: incidental, implicit, 아이들 多